460 bottles · ranked bottles have 5+ ratings
A community catalog of American whiskey
Common Cask maps 653 bottles from 35 distilleries and independent bottlers — bourbon, rye, wheated bourbon, Tennessee whiskey and American single malt — each with its proof, age, suggested retail price, rarity and a community rating out of 10, drawn from 20,853 ratings. No sponsored placements and no paid rankings.
Use the explorer above to search, sort and group every bottle, and select one to see its details or rate it. Most ratings are scores from public whiskey reviews on Reddit; the rest come from members here. How ratings work.
Missing something? Sign in and use Submit a Bottle — every entry is reviewed before it goes live.
Top-rated bottles
Ranked by average rating; a bottle needs at least 5 ratings to qualify.
- 1Russell's Reserve 15 YearWild Turkey Distillery9.2 · 54
- 2Michter's 20 Year BourbonMichter's Distillery9.1 · 28
- 3Barrell Gold Label SeagrassBarrell Craft Spirits9.1 · 8
- 4Sagamore 9-Year-Old Straight Rye WhiskeySagamore Spirit9.0 · 12
- 5Still Austin Tanager 2025Still Austin Whiskey Co.8.9 · 8
- 6George T. Stagg (BTAC)Buffalo Trace Distillery8.7 · 342
- 7Parker's Heritage Wheated MashHeaven Hill Distillery8.7 · 7
- 8William Larue Weller (BTAC)Buffalo Trace Distillery8.6 · 196
- 9Heaven Hill 19 Year Heritage CollectionHeaven Hill Distillery8.6 · 38
- 10American Light Whiskey 17 YearPenelope Bourbon8.6 · 5
Best by style
The three highest-rated bottles in each style.
Bourbon · 340 bottles
Wheated Bourbon · 59 bottles
High Rye Bourbon · 43 bottles
Rye Whiskey · 135 bottles
Tennessee Whiskey · 21 bottles
Wheat Whiskey · 6 bottles
American Single Malt · 4 bottles
Browse by distillery
- Ampersand1
- Angel's Envy Distillery24
- Augusta Distillery5
- Bardstown Bourbon Company50
- Barrell Craft Spirits26
- Barton 1792 Distillery10
- Beam Suntory69
- Bomberger's Declaration9
- Brown-Forman61
- Buffalo Trace Distillery61
- Bulleit Distilling Co.10
- Cascade Hollow Distilling Co.6
- Four Gate Whiskey Company17
- Four Roses Distillery26
- Green River3
- Heaven Hill Distillery47
- High West Distillery14
- Holladay Distillery1
- Jefferson's Bourbon8
- Kentucky Peerless Distilling Co.12
- Leopold Bros.8
- Maker's Mark16
- Michter's Distillery11
- New Riff Distilling16
- NuLu (PCS Distilling)12
- Penelope Bourbon23
- Rabbit Hole Distillery5
- Redwood Empire Whiskey18
- Sagamore Spirit22
- Smooth Ambler Spirits9
- Still Austin Whiskey Co.14
- Templeton Rye9
- Wild Turkey Distillery17
- Wilderness Trail Distillery5
- Willett Distillery8